Forever Young Information

Canada's Adult Lifestyle Publication

BOB’S BLOG: Allan Cup has a century of great hockey memories

By Bob Wood
Whitby Dunlops Charlie Burns (left, in helmet) and Alf Treen lift general manager Wren Blair after the club's Allan Cup victory in 1957. Also on the team were (l to r) Ed Redmond (in tie), Frank Bonello, Don McBeth (looking over Burns' shoulder) and Bob Attersley. Blair family photo
Alf Treen, left, and Charlie Burns watched Doug Williams take his first sip from the Allan Cup after the Whitby Dunlops won the final in 1957. Photo supplied by Williams family.
The OHA and the Hockey Hall of Fame the Dundas Museum and Archives displayed the Allan Cup and other Dundas memorabilia April 1-9, 2014. Submitted by Clare Crozier, President of Dundas Museum and Archives
Some of the '52-'53 Allan Cup champion K-W Dutchmen got together at a reunion in Waterloo in 2002. (l. to r.) Doug Verity, Don Rope, Greig Hicks, Bob Schnurr, Harry Psutka, and Maurice Levesque. Photo: Peter Lee, The Record
Members of the 1969 Allan Cup winning Galt Hornets hoisted the Cup at a reunion hosted by the Cambridge Winter Hawks in 1999. Left to right are goalie Boat Hurley, team president Gord Renwick, Coach Norm Defelice, Manager Wes Lillie and team captain centre Joe Hogan. David Bebee, Record staff
2003 Allan Cup Final between Alberta’s Stoney Plain, Alberta Eagles and Manitoba’s Ile de Chenes North Stars, held at the Dundas Arena in Dundas, Ont. Ron Pozzer, The Spectator.
Long-time NHL defenceman Jay McKee plays for the Dundas Real McCoys, set to compete for the Allan Cup in Dundas from April 14-19. Spectator file photo
Blogs, News&Views Slideshow
April 10, 2014 - 0 comments

Hockey fans looking forward to an alternative to the Stanley Cup playoffs – one with significant Canadian content – should check out the upcoming Allan Cup tournament, the Canadian Senior Men’s Hockey Championship for amateur players.  It is coming up in Dundas from April 14-19.

I attended the last time the Cup was hosted by the Dundas Real McCoys. That was in 2003 when Manitoba’s Ile de Chenes North Stars defeated Alberta’s Stony Plain Eagles in double overtime.

Nineteen teams from across the country have been playing through this long winter to qualify.  Six remain and will be playing off in the west Hamilton suburb that is the self-proclaimed Cactus Capital of Canada.

The Allan Cup is more than a century old. When professionals came into hockey in eastern Canada early last century, amateur players were pretty much without a championship.  Then in 1908 Sir H. Montagu Allan, banker, ship owner and avid sportsman, stepped up to fill the void, donating a cup to be presented to the amateur champions of Canada.

The first winner in 1909 was the Ottawa Cliffsides.  Except for 1945, the Allan Cup has been awarded every year since.  It has been won by teams representing every province and one territory (Yukon.)  That makes it a true national event. I’ll make that case notwithstanding seven championships taken by American teams.

Back in Dundas in 2003, I enjoyed the relatively nonstop action of the game and the high level of competition.  For my reasonably priced ticket ($8, as I recall) I was able to take a seat in the second row right behind the benches.  From that kind of vantage point, it is hard to argue that live hockey is not the best game around. And it is good hockey – the Dundas Real McCoys this year have four former NHLers on their roster.

I’ll confess I’m not a big hockey fan but I’m always interested in tradition.  And this tournament has a rich history and lots of great stories.

Here are some of my favourites. 

The Toronto Dentals won in 1917.  At least five of the players on this squad made it to the NHL.  Future NHLers included the goalie, Charles “Doc” Stewart, and North Bay-born defenseman Stanley Brown.  Rod Smylie retired from pro hockey to become a Doctor.  Stewart and Brown went on to careers in dentistry – certainly a good fit with hockey.

Until 1963, the Allan Cup winner represented Canada at the world championships. Trail Smoke Eaters won in ’38.  John McReedy, one of their players, was part of the team’s senior victory that year and nex season was off to Kirkland Lake to help the Blue Devils win the Allan Cup of 1940.  Remarkably, McReedy was part of the Maple Leaf Stanley Cup victories in 1942 and 45.  McReedy’s incredible record of being part of champion teams had begun as a high scoring forward with the 1937 Memorial Cup-winning Winnipeg Monarchs.  The Monarchs  captured the country’s junior championship that year by beating the Cooper Cliff Redmen.

Steve Saprunoff was the Trail Smoke Eater mascot and stick boy during the 1930s. He headed overseas in the Air Force early in World War II.  Saprunoff was wearing a Smoke Eater jersey under his flight jacket when shot down over Berlin.  While confined to a POW camp a guard recognized that jersey. The guard, a hockey fan, gave Saprunoff special preferential treatment until VE Day when Steve was liberated.  On May 8, 1945, he was still wearing the sweater.

The Belleville McFarlands won the ‘58 Allan Cup.  They were named for their owner, H.J. McFarland, a wealthy industrialist and big hockey fan and long-serving mayor of nearby Picton.

Apparently, the McFarlands played a physical style that drew plenty of complaints from Europeans. But, in the world championship held in Czechoslovakia, they prevailed over the Soviets.  That made them the last Allan Cup Champs to win the world championship. It was a huge moment in Belleville history. See this clip

The McFarlands, however, weren’t the last amateur Canadian team to win the worlds.  That would be those Smoke Eaters again.  The Smokies did not win the Allan Cup in 1961.  That honour went to the Chatham Maroons and their superb Trail-born goalie Cesare Maniago.  The Maroons couldn’t afford to get to the worlds so Trail replaced them.  It would be another 33 years until Canada again won a world championship – this time with a team of professionals.  

There are many other great Allan Cup stories.  You can find more HERE. FYI readers will have their own favourites too – we would love to hear them, make a comment below. 

Bob Wood is a housing and poverty advocate and former two-term Burlington City Councillor who has built a bed-and-breakfast with his wife on Lake Erie. 


Follow-up on visit by Brown Booby

1 day till Sochi, five to watch for Canada

2 days till Sochi! Olympic trivia, A to Z

Olympic Memories: Insbruck, Jan. 29 to Feb. 9, 1964

Welcome to 2014: Listless no more

Orillia builds community through street art

1972 Grey Cup between Ticats, Western Rider was memorable

Birders following fate of rare Brown Booby

Assistant B&B Manager wonders if live will imitate art

150 years of sporting encounters

Who are Twitter's Movers and Shakers?

Bed and breakfast is off and running – me, not so much

Bidini's Book offers background on Homeless World Cup

We already spoke, Canada Post

Bird of the Month: the Fish Crow

Bird of the Month: Red-bellied Woodpecker

Women's hockey in the '30s rivalled the men's for popularity

Visit Scaterie Island, NS to see a real, live (hazardous) shipwreck

Bird of the Month is the Great Gray Owl

For one brief moment, I clamped down on a police budget

Moose and Gray Jays make our day in Algonquin Park

Inflation hits the word 'iconic'

Grey Cup, A to Z

Ealey profile on TSN worthy addition to Grey Cup celebration

The sewage lagoon: good news and bad news for our B&B

Resurrecting Harper's pet project: revise our national anthem

Apparently running a bed and breakfast is not exactly ‘slowing down’

Football follies: if not the Ticats, then Biggleswade. Or Ebbsfleet

How about truly Canadian Olympic games?

Birdwatching in the backyard – count me in

Assignment: be insightful and funny  


No comments have been posted yet.

Leave a Comment

Please confirm you are human:

What is the capital of Canada?